Showing posts with label family carers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label family carers. Show all posts

Wednesday, 18 November 2026

From DLA to Adulthood: My Thoughts on the Milburn Report

 Last week saw the publication of From a Welfare State to a Working State, the final report of Alan Milburn's review into young people, work and welfare. The full report can be read here, along with the executive summary. Gov.UK Link

As the parent of a disabled young man who is approaching adulthood, I was always going to read it with interest. The social media reaction has been mixed. Some people have welcomed the proposals, others are deeply concerned about what they might mean for disabled young people, and a fair amount of speculation has filled the gaps where details do not yet exist.

Having now read the report, my own view is that there are reasons for cautious optimism, reasons for understandable concern, and a great many unanswered questions. Most importantly, it is worth remembering that this is a report, not a change to the law.

The first thing I think families should bear in mind is that nothing changes tomorrow morning. These are recommendations to Government. Ministers may accept some of them, reject others, amend some beyond recognition, or decide not to proceed with particular proposals at all. Even if the Government accepts the broad direction of travel, there would then need to be policy development, consultation, legislation, parliamentary scrutiny, implementation planning and transition arrangements before anyone's benefits changed. The report itself envisages a phased introduction rather than a sudden switch-over.

In an online world where a report can be published in the morning and by lunchtime people are convinced their benefits have already been abolished, it is worth taking a breath. We are at the very start of a process, not the end of one.

One proposal that I actually welcome is the recommendation to extend Child Disability Living Allowance to age 18 rather than requiring disabled young people to move onto an adult benefit at 16.

This has always struck me as one of the oddities of the current system. At 16, many disabled young people are still in school, still living at home and still receiving support through children's services. In many cases, very little changes in their day-to-day lives. Yet they are required to move from a childhood disability benefit into an adult assessment process.

Extending DLA to 18 feels more aligned with how most other systems view the transition to adulthood. It acknowledges that a 16-year-old is still very much a child, even if the benefits system currently treats them otherwise.

I would go a step further. Young people with significant disabilities often remain in education beyond their 18th birthday. My own son Andrew will finish his educational placement in the academic year in which he turns 19. There is a reasonable argument that disability support should align not simply with a birthday but with the completion of a young person's school or college journey. Whether Government would ever embrace that additional complexity is another matter, but I think there is a discussion worth having.

The area generating the most discussion online at the moment is the absence of detail about passported benefits. The report proposes replacing PIP for most under-25s with a new "Additional Cost Allowance" while creating a separate and more generous long-term support arrangement for those with profound and lifelong disabilities.

What it does not do is explain how every related scheme would operate under that new system. That has led to understandable questions. What happens to Carer's Allowance? What happens to Motability? What happens to all the other support schemes that currently rely on entitlement to DLA or PIP?

Those are perfectly valid questions. However, I think it is important not to jump from "the report doesn't say" to "therefore nobody has thought about it". If a Government ever chose to introduce a replacement for PIP, it would inevitably have to decide how all those linked schemes would work. Those decisions would form part of the later policy and legislative process.

That does not mean families should stop asking questions. Quite the opposite. These are exactly the questions disability organisations, carers' organisations and welfare advisers should be asking. But the absence of detail today is not evidence that those decisions have already been made behind closed doors. It simply reflects the fact that this is a strategic review rather than draft legislation.

The section of the report that I found most relevant to families like ours is the proposal for a separate category of long-term support for young people with the most profound and complex disabilities. The report explicitly recognises that some disabled young people will require intensive support and that a smaller group will need secure long-term protection because conventional participation is simply not a realistic expectation. It proposes what it calls a "Severe and Complex Needs Insurance" for that group.

My own reading is that Andrew would be highly likely to fall into that category. He has profound and lifelong disabilities. Nobody looking at his circumstances could realistically conclude that he is temporarily out of work and simply requires a bit more confidence, a training course or an interview suit. The report appears to recognise that distinction.

What none of us know, however, is what this new scheme would actually look like. We do not know what evidence would be required. We do not know how assessments would be conducted. We do not know what level of financial support would be available. We do not know how it would interact with other systems or whether it would provide access to the same passported benefits currently associated with DLA and PIP. Those details simply do not exist yet.

For our family, that means waiting patiently and seeing what emerges if these recommendations progress further. There is little value in panicking over a system that has not yet been designed.

At the same time, I think it is important to acknowledge that many other families may feel rather differently. Andrew is nearly an adult. Even if these proposals eventually become law, there is every chance that any changes would arrive too late to have much effect on his transition into adulthood.

Parents of younger disabled children do not have that luxury. If your child is ten, twelve or fourteen, these proposals could potentially shape the system they encounter as they grow up. It is entirely understandable that those families feel anxious. They are trying to picture a future that has not yet been fully drawn.

For now, I think the most sensible approach is to stay informed, read beyond the headlines, and pay attention to what is actually being proposed rather than what social media fears might be proposed. There are elements of this report that I welcome. There are elements that concern me. There are many important questions that still need answers.

Above all, though, there is one point worth repeating: this is the start of a conversation, not the end of it. The details that will matter most to disabled young people and their families have yet to be written. Until they are, I suspect all any of us can do is watch, ask sensible questions, and avoid assuming either the best or the worst.